Haunted Pubs Of Victoria – A Quick List

In the course of my adult life, I have haunted many pubs across inner Melbourne in particular, as well as having visited many more around greater Melbourne and out in the country.

I have never actually seen any ghosts or had any supernatural experiences, and in the bright light of mid afternoon as I write these words, I do feel a little regretful about that, even though I am quite skeptical about those things.

But, as Shakespeare put it in Hamlet: ‘There is more to heaven and earth, Horatio, than is dreamt of in your philosophy’.

Whilst I have never seen any ghosts, several people I know whom I respect as being rational and reliable people, including one pub manager, have had supernatural experiences, and I thought it might be fun to list some of the pubs which are reputed to be haunted.

1. Young and Jacksons

Young and Jacksons is the most famous pub in Melbourne, as just about all five million people living in our city would know. This comes from it being on the prominent corner of Flinders and Swanston, just over from the main railway station, and from the famous nude painting, Chloe, whose presence has graced the pub for over a hundred years.

Obviously a pub this famous and iconic in Australia needs to be haunted, and it is claimed that the ghost of a murdered prostitute can be heard screaming outside late at night.

To me, this is a very disappointing account, as you would hope that a pub this big and so long established would have a few more ghosts elsewhere on the licensed premises.

2. Mitre Tavern

The Mitre is possibly the oldest building in central Melbourne, and one of the only six pre-gold rush buildings left (the others being the Duke of Wellington, St Francis Church, Rutherglen House in Highlander Lane, the small shop on the corner of King and Latrobe, and that big shopping block which holds the Paperback on Bourke Street). 

I have not really frequented the Mitre that much until recently, but it has become my favourite city pub in the past two years, with its old local pub charm and its upstairs steakhouse, and its rickety structure.

The Mitre makes a big deal of being haunted by Connie Waugh, whose portrait hangs in the stairway up to the steakhouse. Connie was the mistress of one of the early Clarke baronets (famous for hosting a party where the Ashes were created at their Rupertswood Manor in Sunbury) and who had a townhouse opposite the Mitre (now the Savage Club). She reputedly killed herself inside the Mitre and her ghost haunts it.

This might not be so. When chatting with one of the barmaids last year, I was informed that Connie actually killed herself in Adelaide. HOWEVER, there have been other untimely deaths, such as two brothers who fought a gunfight outside in the dead end (sic) alley that we now call Mitre Lane.

Some entity may indeed haunt the Mitre. That same barmaid told me that a vodka bottle had explicably dropped from above the bar (one spirit being jealous of being unloved compared to the other?), and that one night, a time lapse security camera had recorded that a glass had moved on a table without any persons being present.

3. The Imperial

Of all the pubs in the city, the Imperial is the one for which I would express the most love. I spent a lot of time there in the late 1990s and early 2000s as a regular, and even now that I am retired a month does not go past without me stopping in there at least once.

Back when I was a regular, I was very friendly with the pub management, and would ofttimes drink with them when they were off duty. One of those managers told me that the most famous ghost of Melbourne, the late opera singer Federicci, who is known for haunting the Princess Theatre a few doors up, also haunts the Imperial. It seems that Federicci, like me, had many happy memories of times drinking in the Imperial before his untimely demise, so he likes to visit it when he is not employed in haunting his former place of employment.

This manager told me that the publican in the mid 1990s who used to live upstairs had many unnerving experiences late at night, and that he himself had one odd experience. The manager was, at about 1pm one night, doing the paperwork in the upstairs office when the lid on a flip top bin started flipping violently. He wearily looked at it and said ‘Quit it Fred’ and it stopped.

Barmaids at the time (and the Imperial probably had the best looking barmaids in Melbourne back then) also claimed of feeling a presence when they were changing out of their street clothes upstairs. This would be very much in character with Federici’s reputation.

4. The Maori Chief

The Maori Chief is a very old school type pub in South Melbourne, which, alas is temporarily (I hope) closed for renovations.

I recall reading an article in street magazine The Big Issue back in the late 1990s where the publicans claimed that the pub was haunted by the Maori Chief. At that time, the pub would host strippers on Friday afternoons. Supposedly, the ghost of the Chief would get excited and his portrait would fall off the wall.

That won’t be happening anytime soon. Even if the Maori Chief reopens, we are in a different era and the only pub in the city which might entertain strippers these days is the Royal in Punt Road.

5. The Steam Packet

The Steam Packet is, as befits its name, a pub in Williamstown. 

There is a story about an opera singer who was staying there and who lost his voice. As a result he killed himself and now haunts the hotel.

As I have friends who live in Williamstown and regularly dine in the Packet, I might investigate this story further myself sometime soon.

6. Rob Roy (now The Workers Club)

The Rob Roy is in Fitzroy and would be one of the older pubs in Melbourne. It is rumoured that a cleansing took place when it was converted into a Backpacker hostel several years ago to remove the ghosts.

It had a sinister atmosphere, where a bathroom mirror would often fall onto the floor and where a locked storage area was constantly messed up. My informant told me that a barmaid claimed that a dark cloud would float around the ceiling of the bar area late at night.

A medium supposedly communicated with the dead and found that there were many spirits there, but that they welcomed the company.

7. The Middle Hotel Ferntree Gully

Let me preface this bit with the admission that I get very confused about places like Ferntree Gully as it is far from my home in the western suburbs. There are several pubs, and I am not sure that the Ferntree Gully Hotel is the one which is sometimes known as the Middle Hotel.

In any event, there were offices in the upstairs at the Middle Hotel which were abandoned because of supernatural activity, and that something had scratched a woman who worked there.

8. The Palace Hotel

The Palace Hotel is in Burke Road Camberwell, and is currently one of those giant venues where many people frequent. About a decade ago, I would go there fairly regularly to hang out with a friend who was living in Ashburton.

I feel that all the people and poker machines etc would scare away any spirits which were not drinkable, but I might be wrong. My informant has told me that there was a locked office upstairs which was inexplicably trashed overnight.

9. Railway Hotel, Brunswick

Like most of the old pubs in Melbourne, the Railway doubled as a morgue in its early days. It has recently reopened after years of being derelict, and the new owners are making the most of promoting its chequered history, including all the characters who used to frequent it. 

Unsurprisingly, it is being claimed as being haunted. People say that they have heard things moving when they are alone, and when they turn, they do not see anyone. Two former publicans died on the premise.

I’m not sure as to whether this is just positive publicity on the part of the owners, or whether there is depth to these rumours.

10. Prince of Wales, Seymour

The Prince of Wales in Seymour is reputed to be haunted, but I do not have more details.

11. The Royal Hotel, Seymour

The Royal in Seymour has an abundance of public information about being haunted. It was used as a morgue, back in the olden days, and the head of Mad Dan Morgan, one of the most vicious bushrangers, hung in the bar after he was finally hunted down.

Or so I learned this morning when browsing a book about haunted places in Australia in the QBD bookshop.

According to some casual searching on Google, there are ghost tours who visit it in the hope of experiencing ghosts.

12. Toolleen Hotel

The Toolleen Hotel has a creepy atmosphere at night and when my informant lived there, her dog refused to go inside. A baby died in there and that perhaps is the reputed ghost.

13. The Plough Hotel, Myrniong

The Plough is another pub reputed to be haunted, although I do not have details.

14. St Andrews Hotel

When I was told that the St Andrews Hotel was haunted, I had to double check, as I initially hoped that it was the pub in Fitzroy which was known as the Pumphouse for several decades, and which I visited several times each year.

Alas, it was not so – it is the pub in the town of St Andrews (which is most well known for suffering terribly during the Black Saturday bushfires) which has the ghosts. It was used as a morgue.

15. Blackwood Hotel

Back around 2007-8 I was a member of a pub crawl group (the Great Intercontinental Pub Crawl) which would take a bus out into the Macedon Ranges for the day. Hence I am pretty sure that I have visited the Blackwood Hotel. 

The owners claim that it is the ‘best haunted pub’ in Blackwood although that is not why I visited. Apparently it has a rich history of ghost stories and paranormal investigators frequently visit with their gadgets to suss out supernatural activity.

16. The Kangaroo Hotel, Maldon

I did visit Maldon once, and I have been to the Kangaroo Hotel there, the only pub named after our national emblem. The pub was used as a morgue, which seems (from what I have read in researching this posting) a common reason as to why a pub will be haunted.

Aside from that, a stable fire in 1870 killed ten horses who haunt it, and in 1907 the publican threw himself down the well.

Nowadays, ghost tours like to visit it.

17. Argyle Hotel (Irish Murphy), Geelong West

The Irish Murphy in Geelong was nicknamed The Strangler’s Arms in the 1950s after a woman was killed there. Personally, I prefer that sort of nickname for a pub rather than transforming it into a Plastic Paddy.

News reports claim that glasses are hurled across rooms (without the prerequisite accompanying drunkards who usually perform such actions), urns get moved, doors slammed shut and terrifying voices hissing into the ears of staff and patrons. The poltergeist is affectionally named Mary.

18. The Coach and Horses Inn, Clarkefield

The Coach and Horses Inn was built by the Clarke family, whom I have already mentioned above in connection with the Mitre Tavern. It is claimed to be the most haunted pub in Australia, with at least three ghosts. Those are an autistic girl who was thrown down a well by her father, an Irish seaman who was robbed and killed, and a Chinese miner who was hanged in the stables.

I’m pretty sure that this was the pub which was mentioned in some paranormal special on TV in the mid 1980s. One of my year 12 maths teachers (I did double maths plus physics and chemistry for HSC) told us that he had been in there and the atmosphere was sinister.

19. Elephant Bridge Hotel

The delightfully named Elephant Bridge Hotel is the main attraction if you want to visit the village of Darlington in the west of Victoria. It has four ghosts, including a young woman, a man in his thirties, and a child who drowned there.

The fourth ghost is Adeline Eliza Satchwell, the longest serving publican, who died in 1943.

Reports of these ghosts make me rather curious about visiting this pub.

20. Craig’s Hotel, Ballarat

Walter Craig, the owner of the eponymous Craig’s Hotel, reportedly had a dream in 1870 that his horse was going to win the Melbourne Cup ridden by a jockey wearing a black armband.

He died soon after this dream of gout and pneumonia and his horse Nimblefoot did indeed win the Cup, ridden by a jockey (John Day) who wore a black armband in respect of the owner.

Apparently this story is a fabrication, but as the old saying goes, never let the truth get in the way of a good story, and it does make the rounds, lending some supernatural appeal to Craig’s Hotel.

21. Criterion Hotel, Rushworth

People have reported cold spots, strange noises and footsteps, and even worse, inexplicably warm beer at this pub.

Paranormal investigators have identified a ghost named Kevin in one room of the pub, although a businessman named Ted Read committed suicide in the pub in 1912 with the help of a shotgun and could also be a candidate for long term occupant.

Sadly, whilst there is a Kevin, there are no Karens haunting the pub. On second thought, this could be a good thing.

22. Cosmopolitan Hotel, Trentham

This pub has apparently been haunted by the ghost of a young girl with dark hair for over a century.

23. Nelson Hotel, Nelson

Not to be confused with the Lord Nelson in Sydney, which has its own rather famous ghost. The Nelson is in far south-western Victoria. It is believed to be haunted by the ghost of a young woman who had been kept locked in the pub’s cellar.

24. Dinner Plain Hotel, Dinner Plain

The person who informed me about the Dinner Plain Hotel advised that several people they knew have worked there and all heard voices of young women and presences within the pub. A few shadowy figures have been spotted, especially when heading upstairs.

25. Customs House Hotel, WIlliamstown

On a recent visit to Williamstown to watch a friend’s band play at the Customs House Hotel, I asked the bar staff if the pub had any stories about being haunted. They advised in the affirmative.

As the pub was opposite the old Customs House, there was a tunnel from the cellar to the Customs House. When ships docked in Williamstown, the bodies of people who had died in transit would be transferred through that tunnel to the pub cellar which served as a makeshift morgue (as indeed have many pubs in Greater Melbourne). Ghosts include that of a girl.

Concluding Comments

This blog post was not possible without a couple of weeks of casual research, including getting input from some people on an Australian Pubs page on Facebook.

I have excluded places like the Windsor Hotel because whilst it is claimed to be haunted it is a major hotel rather than a pub, and similarly I have excluded bars and night clubs. I have also excluded private clubs (like the Kelvin Club which I regularly frequent) because they are private clubs, not public houses, and I have yet to hear stories about ghosts in those.

I am really curious to collect more ghost stories about pubs, so would welcome much feedback and input.

Tomayto Tomahto

Green zebras

Being of Italian peasant origins (aside from the recent discovery of a Count four generations back in the family tree) I like attempting to grow tomatoes every summer.

Aside from my first year in Avondale Heights, this has been with limited success.

Not to jinx it, but this year looks like giving me my best crop in 20 years. The first to be picked are some green zebras, a striped tomato which is a yellowish green when ripe and very delicious.

Much Ado About Sydney…

As far as film adaptations of Shakespeare’s plays go, Sir Kenneth Brannagh’s work over the past 35 years has given me particular enjoyment. Henry V in 1989 revived interest in Shakespeare, and his version of Hamlet was closest to the full written play (although proven by experts to be far too long to have been what actually was original performed at the Globe) than any other movie version. I found his version of Love’s Labour’s Lost (with such co-stars as Alicia Silverstone, the delectable Natasha McElhone, and the way underrated Matthew Lillard) to have great energy and fun.

I have only been disappointed with Brannagh with his performance in Othello (which he did not direct) as Iago, one of my two absolute favourite villains in the First Folio (the other, if you are curious, is Richard III).

But the most fun I have had in watching Brannagh’s ‘Shakespearances’ (I just made that word up – aren’t I clever?!?) is Much Ado About Nothing, which he directed and co-starred in about 30 years ago. The chemistry between himself as Benedick and his then wife Dame Emma Thompson as Beatrice was amazing. He had a great supporting line up, including Denzel Washington as Don Pedro, Keanu Reeves (always a fan favourite) as the villain Don John, and Michael Keaton in a bit role as Dogberry, the comic relief.

And more importantly, that film marked the screen debut of my absolute favourite actress, Kate Beckingsale, as Hero. Mind you, Hero is very much a passive character in that play and Kate’s performance was totally overshadowed by the chemistry between Sir Kenneth and Dame Emma in the lead roles.

As was everyone else, to be honest. [FYI, I did not really fall in love with Kate til I saw her amazing lead performance in Cold Comfort Farm two years later.]

Brannagh’s efforts, particularly after the initial success of Henry V, inspired other film adaptations of Shakespeare. Suddenly Mel Gibson wanted to play Hamlet, Sir Ian McKellen (a co-star in Cold Comfort Farm with Kate) gave us a mind blowingly awesome art deco adaption of Richard III in the mid 1990s, and Alan Hopkins’ portrayal of Titus Andronicus in the film version was aptly cannibalistic.

Baz Lehrman did Romeo + Juliet with Leonardo Di Caprio and Claire Daines in the title roles, a version which, I felt at the time had editing inspired by Pepsi Max commercials, but which has grown on me the more I have come to overlook his youthful brattiness and appreciate Di Caprio’s talent as an actor.

Stanley Tucci as Puck in the 1999 production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream stole the show, as did Sir Ben Kingsley as the fool in Twelfth Night in that same golden decade of Shakespearances (see – I have found a use for my new word).

I do think though that the Melbourne gangland inspired production of Macbeth in 2005 missed the point as making all the characters gangsters means that everyone is a villain, which is not what Macbeth is about.

We also had an abundance of film adaptions which were based on Shakespeare, but which did not quite follow the script. Ones which come to mind are O, which was Othello in a high school basketball team with Josh Barnett as ‘Hugo’, the Iago villain, and Ten Things I Hate About You, which introduced American audiences to a teenage Heath Ledger in a high school rom-com version of The Taming of the Shrew. Julia Stiles was the female lead in the latter, and probably (although I am not too certain and can’t be bothered looking it up) in the former.

Boxing Day saw another loose adaptation of Shakespeare hit the cinemas, the rom-com Anyone But You, starring current ‘It Girl’ Sydney Sweeney as ‘Bea’ opposite a romantic lead named ‘Ben’ in a clash of wits during a destination wedding set on Sydney Harbour.

I like the escapism of cinema, as well as seeing beautiful women in bikinis, and so I went to see this film. I did not actually pick up on the abundant hints that this was loosely based on Much Ado About Nothing until about half an hour into the film when the supporting characters start to try and manipulate the leads into thinking that each is secretly in love with the other.

The bits where they dig out phrases and ham acting from the play to obviously talk in a way as to be both overheard by Bea and Ben, and to be understood by the audience as to the motives, come across to me as rather charming, rather than awkward. If this was a standard rom-com, this would not work, but when you are clearly basing something on the Bard, it adds greater value to the entire endeavour, a bit like the absence of horses in Monty Python’s Holy Grail.

I also found the almost cringe-worthily stereotypical Aussie surfer comic relief with his broad Australian accent and vocabulary to be very amusing, rather than offensive, and spent quite some time wondering how the script writers had been able to come up with his dialogue. Did they get a linguistics professor to advise them?

At least one of my friends deplores my taste in film and TV, which is quite low brow (I did see Baywatch and Wonder Woman on the same day after all) in comparison to my taste in literature. But I like what I like, and if I see a rom-com which is made somewhat cleverer by being spiced by Shakespeare, then I can reach a happy medium between the two extremes.

Irredentism – An Irredeemable & Immature Ideology

When I was nine years old, I became aware of the extent of the Roman Empire, in which Italy, my ancestral homeland, was the dominant part. I felt rather indignant (being ethnically Italian) that Rome did not still rule all shores and hinterlands of the Mediterranean.

Without knowing it at the time, I was an Italian Irredentist, a believer in the political fiction that a modern state has a right to reclaim (with or without consent of its inhabitants) territory formerly ruled by a predecessor state.

A nine year old can be excused for being an Irredentist. It is, after all, an ideology extremely appealing to the immature, and who can be more immature than a nine year old?

Irredentism is a fairly new addition to both my vocabulary and my working knowledge of political philosophy. It came into my consciousness mostly thanks to the recent manifestation of Russian Irredentism through Putin’s aggression towards the Ukraine.

But it is very much Italian in origin. The term comes from the slogan Italia Irredenta (Unredeemed Italy) relating to the late 19th century desire by Italian nationalists to reclaim various areas occupied by other adjacent states to the newly reunited Italian nation.

[As an aside, there is another similar nationalist ideology, Revanchism (from the French word Revanche – for Revenge), which relates to wanting to recapture territory lost in a recent war and which arose around the same time.]

When I was in Genoa during my recent trip to Italy, I found myself highly disturbed by a particular public square, in which there stands a war memorial dedicated to all the Italian soldiers lost during the First World War. This square is surrounded by buildings, which, from their architectural style, were clearly built during the Fascist era.

I saw the entire square as a tragic but unconscious memorial to Italian Irredentism, which prompted me to want to write this post.

For me, it is a highly personal matter. Both my grandfathers served on the Italian front in the First World War. My namesake grandfather, a corporal-major in the infantry, suffered capture and was a prisoner of war in Hungary for several years. The other grandfather was a machine gunner throughout the war, a macabre and violent duty that would have haunted him the rest of his life.

Looking at the maps of the front, I am well aware that my paternal ancestral village was as far from the front line as my mother’s home in Maribyrnong is from Solomon’s Ford, the river crossing near my home. That puts the war in sobering context, right on my family’s doorstep.

Then, with the debacle that was Italy’s participation in the Second World War, there was fighting around both my parents’ villages, at either ends of the country. They were children at the time, and they both vividly recounted their memories of that period.

Members of the extended family were killed in both wars. And for what?

In, as a mature adult, denouncing the highly immature and irresponsible idea of Irredentism, I see that there were two types of Irredentism at play in the Italian state, driving Italy unnecessarily into two costly and devastating wars.

The first form of Irredentism is bourgeois in nature. This is what we have to thank for plunging Italy into the First World War. A desire to claim territory occupied partly by Italian speakers which was within the Austro-Hungarian empire drove the Italian bourgeois to force the government to declare war.

The government of the time had little ability to control this groundswell of idiocy. Austria-Hungary, already beset with its own commitments through having started an ill-considered war, was anxious not to have to open a new front on the Italian border. It was willing to make territorial concessions and let Italy have much of what it wanted without a fight.

However, the irredentists felt that land gained without the shedding of blood was unearned. War was seen as necessary. [If you want to read more for yourself on this mindset, I suggest the biography of Gabriele D’Annunzio by Lucy Hughes-Hallet: The Pike, London 2013, pp 352-369.]

The direct result of that war was 351,000 dead Italian men – few of whom were professional soldiers, and the suffering of many others forced to participate in this needless war.

Another result of that war was the disaffection of millions of Italians, particularly in the less politically empowered lower classes, with the Italian state, who had bankrupted the nation and failed to deliver the promised territorial gains. Call them peasants, or proletarians, or plebeians, or what you will, there were millions of men who had not had much of a say in the decision to go to war, but had suffered the brunt of it, both at the front and in the bread basket.

Which lit another form of Irredentism, a proletarian form (if you pardon my decision to use Marxist terminology for convenience’s sake). Suddenly, Irredentism became a mass movement of the disempowered and disaffected, people willing to follow the lead of Mussolini, the most bombastic arch-irredentist.

This then led to the Second World War. There were fewer deaths in this one in Italy, 457,000 (of which a third were civilian), but the entire country was devastated by the fighting and by German occupation of much of its territory. This was then followed by the loss of most of the territorial gains from the First World War.

So, when I look at monuments erected a century ago, and the public buildings of that era which surround them, I think of the sad losses which immaturity and stupidity amongst political leaders and their followers caused through their belligerent decisions.

Whilst Irredentism can be excused in children, it cannot be excused in adults. Adults hold political power, both through their individual vote and through holding office. Making decisions based on ideologies based in deep and childish immaturity and petulance is dangerous and inexcusable. For that, Irredentism is, despite the origin of its name, Irredeemable.

The latest on BROO

As regular readers of my blog (if such rare creatures indeed exist outside of mythology) would know, I am the proud shareholder of 120 shares in homegrown craft brewery BROO (ASX Code BEE). 

The entertaining story about I gradually acquired those 120 shares has been told in this blog previously, so I will not reiterate it again, suffice to remind people that BROO has been suspended from trading since early May 2022, that the shares last traded at about 0.9 cents, and that a board coup. by a large minority of shareholders forced out the company founder in March 2022.

Since that time, I bought a frame from the Reject Shop and put the original symbolic share certificate from early 2011 into that frame, and then hung the certificate into a very necessary but smallish room in my home, in pride of place.

To say that I am not counting on BROO to fund my comfortable retirement, or even an afternoon of boozing at the Kelvin Club (currently my watering hole of choice, as befits someone who recently discovered that they are descended from a Count), is to state the bleeding obvious.

Even if BROO was to suddenly emulate the ‘Poseidon Bubble’ from its current share price if it were to start trading again, the proceeds (not counting brokerage) would only at best give me enough to order a dozen bottles of decent but sensibly priced red wine from one of my favourite wine makers (eg Andrew Buller).

But that would be optimistic.

Nevertheless, as those shares still show up as some sort of blemish on my Commsec portfolio, I have little choice but to seek what amusement value I can out of continuing to follow the company on its journey of reinvention.

This is more than what BrewNews, a website dedicated to commercial craft brewing across the ANZ region is willing to do anymore. They have abandoned covering BROO, although their articles on the company from their archives have insights which would be lacking in my own blog postings.

Since late December 2021, when the changing of the board old guard started with the first resignation, there have been been at least nine appointments to the board, and eight resignations from the board. This has included at least three chairmen being appointed and then resigning, with the current (and fourth) chairman (the lyrically named Peter Pan) joining two months ago.

The release of the half year reports to December 2022 gave me some reading material this afternoon. It seems that the directors and other investors are willing to continue to either loan or invest equity in the business, and to keep it afloat.

More to the point, they are also talking about launching a new beer in February 2024.

Which is indicative that there are some people who are very optimistic who are currently leading the business through its period of divestment (ie the Mildura Brewery Pub and the Ballarat brewery site) and reinvention.

This pleases me, as I find following the ongoing story of this company, from when I first acquired shares in it almost 13 years ago, five or six years prior to its listing, quite fascinating.

My one suggestion to them is that they should do as the founder did back then, and offer everyone who buys a slab of beer from them ten shares in the company. This would be a good way of ensuring sales for the first batch of the new beer they are launching in February. I am happy to partake in such an offer, once more, enough though red wine is usually my poison of choice.

On The Western Bulldogs Digital Membership

I’m new to Facebook, and having only joined for communication with relatives in Italy during my recent trip, all I use FB for now is to read those highly addictive Reddit stories (clickbait) about people who have toxic relatives or bosses (this takes up quite a lot of my time, given I find such stories fascinating).

On the rare occasions I read some other FB matters, I have a peak at the various Western Bulldogs fan pages. I am mostly not impressed by the content of those, as there are some rather toxic people who spend their time complaining about everything around the current status of the Club, including demanding the sacking of Luke Beveridge, our senior coach (memo – to these rocket scientists, we have had a premiership in 2016 and a 2021 grand final appearance under this coach, which makes this our Golden Age).

One thing that has triggered me a little is seeing those people who have traditional memberships posting about the arrival of their membership kits, complete with 2024 membership scarves. My own brother has received his kit.

I opted this year for digital membership, which entitles me to a $40 egift card instead of a $20 egift card in the Bulldogs Shop, and no scarf or physical membership card or stickers.

The egift card arrived this week about 6 weeks after I renewed and later than all these non-digital members get their kit of goodies.

Let me make it clear that I do not worry too much about scarves or stickers, and I mostly just pay my $92 or so in membership fees each year as a limited game day member due to my desire to support my Club financially.

But I would say, as a value proposition, the $40 egift card is not great. The extra $20 worth is due to not having the scarf mailed out to me with the kit. The email with the egift card suggested that I could use the egift card to buy a $20 scarf and then use the remainder to buy other merchandise.

Where this is annoying is that postage of merchandise represents a cost of $12.50 – an additional cost to members who, like me, try to buy merchandise online.

Which means that instead of giving digital members a $40 egift card, they should have given us a $52.50 egift card.

But this is a minor grumble. This year, for the first time ever, a long sleeved polo/rugby shirt is available as an option for current members. So I have put the $40 and another $40 (including the postage) into ordering one of those.

When that arrives, I will feel the instant gratification of receiving a new piece of fan gear, one which I will value more than yet another hat or scarf, particularly as my preferred casual wear involves polo shirts.

Australia’s Own Dreyfus Affair

The Dreyfus Affair was a tragic miscarriage of justice during the early years of the French Third Republic. Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a French army officer of Jewish background, was unjustly accused of espionage charges. Motivated by anti-semitism, his principal accusers in the military and the government were blind to evidence pointing conclusively to another officer, who had deep motives to accept bribes from Germany, being financially comprised.

Captain Dreyfus was eventually fully exonerated, after a decade, but not before he had spent several years as a prisoner on Devil’s Island, which ruined his health.

Many of those who sought justice for him were themselves falsely accused, such was the political climate of the time.

This week, we have our own Dreyfus Affair playing out in the courts here in Australia. Army lawyer David McBride is facing serious charges relating to leaking sensitive information to the ABC. Whilst this is not espionage, it is a serious breach of his duties as a member of the defence forces.

The tragic irony of this particular case is that the information McBride leaked to journalists relates to the evidence that there were war crimes allegedly committed by Australian Defence personnel in Afghanistan. Motivated by his conscience, and probably by a reasonably formed opinion that if he were to remain silent, rather than to become a public whistle blower, these alleged war crimes would never see the light of day and the alleged perpetrators would never face justice.

Instead, this week, it is Mr McBride who is facing justice in court.

Legally, I expect that the prosecution case is a strong one – open and shut. Mr McBride has leaked that information in violation of his responsibilities – this is factual and uncontested.

Morally, the matter is obviously more problematic. His defence have argued the laudable, but possibly quixotic, defence argument that he had a duty above that of his oath and the relevant secrecy legislation, to follow his conscience in this matter. This is similar to the arguments of the prosecutors at Nuremberg, that following immoral orders to commit immoral acts was not a defence against the charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity levelled at the Nazis.

The court of appeal has thrown out this defence argument today, and I expect that legally, this is the soundest decision. Courts and judges do need to follow the law in the administration of justice, rather than to make up rules on whim.

As a consequence, it appears according to the news today, that McBride may change his plea to guilty, given that his defence was based on a moral dilemma which has been disallowed.

But the issue which concerns me, and which should concern all Australian citizens, is not what the courts should determine in this matter. I have full confidence that the courts will deliver justice according to what the law stipulates, much as this will have tragic implications for Mr McBride.

The issue that concerns me is why the decision has been made to prosecute Mr McBride with the full force of the law in this matter, one where he despairingly sought to act in what he felt was in the public interest, where significance malfeasance (to put it mildly) was apparent but not being appropriately addressed by the authorities.

Yes, he had access to very sensitive and restricted information, which he had no legal right to reveal. Having the noblest of motives to reveal this in violation of his normal obligations does not diminish the legal liability, but it should mitigate it, and should have guided the hands of those who made the decision to prosecute him.

Instead, we have had a rare show of bipartisanship on the part of our Federal Attorney Generals. It was under the watchful gaze of Christian Porter, one of the least admirable of recent federal ministers, that these charges were laid in September 2018. It is now under current Attorney General, Mark Dreyfus KC, that the charges are proceeding to trial.

I am not alone in my concerns about this matter. Better informed people than myself have articulated their thoughts on this and another ongoing prosecution of a whistleblower:

I feel that the motives for the continuation of this trial is more a matter of protecting the legal sources of government power, which is supported by both sides of politics, given that they wield that power, rather than questioning the morality as to how, why and when that power is wielded by its agents.

The legal matter will result in the punishment of McBride by the law courts. The moral matter is one that we all need to consider ourselves, as the court of public opinion.

The irony and injustice inherent in Mr McBride being the sole person to face a criminal trial so far in relation to the war crimes allegations he revealed does give great reason to question the morality of our elected officials, who are prepared to hide behind the black letter of the law rather than to explore their consciences for a more holistic form of justice.

I hope that fairness prevails, and that Attorney General Dreyfus relents in this matter, and extends mercy to one who sought to expose the mercilessness of others.

Treasury Wine Estates Buys Daou Vineyards

Whilst I was travelling through Italy recently and scrolling through Facebook for the first time ever (the novelty has worn off), I found many ads promoting such investments as buying wine futures or whiskey kegs.

As I do like wine and whiskey, although not necessarily for investment, I did have a close look at those. As a result, I am pondering whether, for the sheer fun of it, to buy a whiskey keg or a carefully curated collection of fine wines as an investment.

My motives for owning 1000 shares in Treasury Wine Estates are rather similar. I like wine sufficiently that I have always been fond of the idea of owning shares in a wine company. In the distant past, I owned shares in the now long gone Fosters Group, Southcorp, and BRL Hardy at various times. More recently, I owned shares in Australian Vintage Group until they announced that they were not going to be paying a dividend this year, so I sold them and put the cash towards my holiday in Italy.

The announcement on Halloween that TWE is going to buy the American Daou Vineyards for $US 1 billion, mostly though a capital raising, piqued my interest as a shareholder.

I think I vaguely recall the Board hinting at the AGM at the imminent purchase when they said something about being interested in buying significant businesses which would complement the existing wine portfolio.

For me, the immediate impact is that I have the renounceable rights to buy 106 additional shares in TWE at a price (if I recall from the announcement) of $10.83 each. This represents a discount of about a dollar on where the share price is right now.

So… do I want to dig up the $1150 to buy those extra TWE shares?

I have decided NO, for several reasons.

First is that my motive for owning TWE shares is because I simply like owning a small part of a large winemaking business, particularly as it enables me to attend and enjoy the Annual General Meeting (all Bin 28 for me thanks, none of that midstrength Pepperjack!). I do not really see TWE as a core part of my share portfolio – the yield is relatively low and there is not that much diversity or growth compared to one of the LICs or ETFs I own, or to Washington Soul H Pattison (ie my main shareholding).

Second is that adding 106 shares spoils the symmetry of my share portfolio and makes my record keeping for possible sale at some point in the future a little messier. I outgrew dividend reinvestment schemes well over a decade ago (I have invested in the share market for about 27 years), and similarly am not so keen on share entitlement offers.

Third is that I can keep my $1150 for when I need it for some other investment. My Italy trip, my retirement party, and my replacement of my hot water service 6 months ago, all have put a bit of a hole in my bank balance, causing any further investments to be delayed for a while. I am much keener on either topping up one or other of my other share holdings, or to buy something entirely new.

And the fourth reason is that the renounceable rights issue could, depending on the share price during this period, result in a small premium being returned to me – money which I can then put aside for either more investment, or for my next big holiday (and no, I am not returning to Italy for at least another 3 years).