$180 Million Flop? Funding Film to Promote Art and Culture….

As I wrote a few days ago, I quite enjoyed Furiosa, the Mad Max spin off film.

Sadly, it appears to have been a flop, which is quite sad as I have always loved Mad Max, and the Roadrunner cartoons (which are the perfect manifestation of this genre).

News reports have emerged that the Australian and NSW taxpayer have been responsible for funding the bulk of this film, with estimates being that the Federal Government has stumped up $150 million and that the NSW Government has put up $33 million.

That is quite a lot of money to put into funding one movie.

The supposed benefits to Australia from funding such a film are two fold. The first is that having such a film made in Australia may provide employment benefits, particularly in the local film industry. The other is that films can contribute to the local arts scene and to Australian culture.

The first argument is a rather Keynesian one, and I am skeptical about it. Pouring a lot of taxpayer money into one film is unlikely to unlock a lot of economic benefits. Keynesian activities, such as subsidised film making, or Kevin Rudd’s various recession avoidance initiatives in the time of the GFC, or other expressions of government largesse, rarely end well.

The willy-nilly use of taxpayer funds with limited accountability does not result in outcomes of great benefit to the community, even though you might argue that the chancers who profit from the loopholes, as in the various GFC era schemes, might trickle their new found riches back into the economy when they increase their luxury spending.

And a lot of the really bad films made in Australia Cinema history are the Ozploitation films from the 1970s and early 1980s, when government policy allowed for extremely generous tax deductions for investment in film making. Like, have you ever seen the 1981 film Starstruck? The only good thing about it is the soundtrack.

The second argument is the somewhat elitist cultural one, that government needs to fund the arts. Our art galleries, operas, ballets, theatre companies, symphony orchestras etc possibly need to have government funding. Similarly our local artist and literary scenes.

This doesn’t always work well either. Some subsidised literary magazines appear to have a censorship agenda where they blacklist writers whose political views do not align with the editors. Quite a lot of the political myth making on television is tax payer subsided, such as some of the distorted views of political history espoused in such ABC miniseries as the 1988 classic ‘True Believers’.

In terms of my own artistic tastes, I am reminded of Dostoyevsky when he wanted to be good. He really wanted to be good and pious and god fearing. However he liked women, vodka and roulette too much.

In a similar vein, I would like to be the sort of person who goes to the Opera, the Symphony, the Ballet, and to gallery openings and exhibitions, whilst sipping a glass of wooded chardonnay in the intermission whilst my ABC bumper sticker wearing Tesla sits in the Arts Centre garage.

But I am not really that sort of person. I am from a working class background in Footscray, with mostly peasant origins (despite being 1/16 of a Count in ancestry). I have some rather bogan tastes, and would prefer to watch an action movie in the cinema and share a bottle of shiraz afterwards.

So, much as I deplore the use of over $180 million of taxpayer money for making a Mad Max film, I prefer to see the money spent on that than on other cultural subsidies like Opera and Ballet.

Because at least there is a very very good chance that I will watch the film.

Reddit – The Rebirth of Greek Tragedy as a Social Media Trainwreck

It took me quite a while to ‘get’ King Lear. Whilst familiar with Macbeth from high school English class, Romeo and Juliet and The Tempest from having read them independently in my teenage years [my initial copy of the Complete Works – I now own four (all unsurprisingly gifted to me) plus separate paperbacks of each play – starts with The Tempest], Henry V from seeing the Branagh production at age 20, and The Taming of the Shrew from going with some friends some time in the late 1990s at the Botanic Gardens for an evening performance, I did not really get into Shakespeare til age 28.

At that time, working for a few months in Box Hill, I had abundant extra time on the train to do some reading. So I packed a paperback of one of the plays each morning as my commute reading. I must say that I found most of them quite enjoyable, and particularly enjoyed the metaphysical nature of Hamlet [a play which is better to read than to see performed in my humble opinion].

But I did not at that time really get why critics generally rate King Lear as one of the four great tragedies. Back then, I saw the great tragedies as having some sort of dualistic moral dilemma: Hamlet has knowledge and innocence, as in the Fall from Grace; Macbeth has guilt and innocence; and Othello has love and jealousy. In my mind, Lear lacked such a dualism. Julius Caesar, with the dilemma of love and duty, more deserved to be considered one of the great plays than Lear.

As you might guess, I had not read any Greek tragedies at that stage, even though quite a few of them were sitting unread in my bookcases. The Clouds, one of the more irreverent comedies by Aristophanes, was the only Greek play with which I had any familiarity.

My opinion of King Lear changed when I first saw it performed live in 2005, which left me quite impressed. A good production of Lear, ending with him grieving Cordelia, can project quite a lot of tragic pathos. This did set me off on a binge of watching live productions of the plays whenever I could, and by now I have seen about two thirds of them performed.

I did get around to reading the Greek tragedies in my late 30s or early 40s, and that did cause me to finally ‘get’ how great King Lear really is.

Lear is the closest that Shakespeare has come to a Greek tragedy in all his works. The themes of vicious betrayal of and by your closest blood relatives is what we most commonly see in the Ancient Greek plays. The most vicious of those are the ones which follow the generations deep curse of the Atreides, seeing this royal lineage constantly caught in a god-ordered cycle of murder, sacrifice, vengeance and exile.

Medea, one of the plays written by Euripides, perhaps is even harsher. Spurned by her lover Jason, the embittered Medea murders their children in a fit of vengeance, then to be born off by the gods in a chariot pulled by dragons.

It perhaps is an understatement when, in the introductory voiceover at the start of each episode of Xena Warrior Princess, we are reminded that the ancient gods were petty and cruel, and plagued mankind with suffering. (Not that Xena, even with the Greek myths and histories to guide the script writers, ever bothered with verisimilitude.)

In recent months, I have become fascinated, like a kangaroo in the spotlight, with the sorts of stories republished in Facebook, and which originate in another social media platform, Reddit. These stories are, to put it nicely, quite horrible, and the most popular ones which my algorithm feeds me are about parents abandoning their children, siblings stealing each other’s spouses or significant others, and dysfunctional step families.

Many of the most popular ones are where, like King Lear (or Agamemnon, if you want to look back at the cursed Atreides of ancient Athens) a parent singles out one of their children for inexplicably vicious treatment whilst the others are given preference. Such mistreatment rarely goes further than neglect or abuse, unlike the actual infanticides (and parricides and matricides) of the Ancient Greek writers, but the general gist of the behaviour is similar: those who are closest to us, who we should most love and trust, are the ones who can hurt us the most.

Twenty years ago, we would have gone to Judge Judy to view the ersatz modern equivalents of Greek tragedy, but now we do not need to reach so far. Social media, in the form of Reddit (and its allies Youtube, TikTok, and Facebook), makes it possible for people to post their stories to a widespread audience in the hope that ‘random internet strangers’ will give their unbiased advice and wisdom.

Perhaps, we, just like the audiences in 5th Century BC Athens, have a similar need to watch these stories, and to be horrified and gratified at the same time by these narrators of these domestic tragedies.

But I do wish that perhaps, we would have greater opportunity to actually see some of those original great Greek tragedies performed live than we currently do.

Where Will We Be in 11 Years? Thoughts On The Uncanny X-Men Revival And Whether Life Really Hurts

It’s nearly time we were leavin’
We’ll have one more for the road
It don’t mean nothin’
It don’t mean nothin’

So we gather ’round the table
Raise our champagne in the air
It don’t mean nothin’
It don’t mean nothin’

‘Cause we’ve got
This night together, we’ll have
Here now forever
Ah, don’t tell me now, you can
Write me a letter
Where will we be in 50 years?
In 50 years?

Uncanny X-Men – May, 1985

I was walking past the Croxton Park Hotel in Thornbury the other day and saw on the upcoming gig guide that Radio Birdman were going to do a 50 year anniversary gig.

I had never listened to any Radio Birdman before, but I do have a friend who is a fan of them, and owns the vinyl of their album Radios Appear, which is how I know the name. My walk inspired me to listen Radios Appear on my Apple Music account the other night, whilst sipping some red wine.

I must admit that it was not really what I expected – it is a bit more punk than what I thought the name promised.

But they are just one of many of the classic Australian bands of my childhood and teenage years who are making a milestone anniversary or farewell tour. Just like TISM, who recently did a lot of guerrilla reunion gigs and released new music.

I guess that in their early senior years (all of these musicians would now qualify for the seniors card, as they are older than me and I am happily retired), a lot of those bands are trying to top up their superannuation balances by tapping into their ageing fan bases. After all, not everyone has been diligently paying 10 per cent into their defined benefit superannuation funds to max out their retirement benefits like yours truly.

One thing that grabbed my attention from the Apple Music algorithmic playlist when I was listening to a lot of music the other night was the addition of two new Uncanny X-Men songs. Given that I do occasionally play ‘Cos Life Hurts, the debut album from this archetypical bogan Melbourne band from the mid 1980s, it is unsurprising that the Apple algorithm would alert me to new music from that band.

And so, I listened to the online EP that Uncanny X-Men just offered the music world. It consists of two songs – It’s A Shame, and We Love It.

It doesn’t really do too much for me, though I suspect that Brian Mannix is doing a sly dig at the weaponisation of gender pronouns in We Love it, which appears to be a commentary on the contemporary world.

After all, the X-Men’s best work was almost 40 years – the bogan anthem Work (which is about not wanting to work, which is apt for a bunch of lads from Braybrook) and the poignant power ballad 50 Years, which was released just over 39 years ago.

39 years…. It is quite sobering to look and see how much time has passed since that ballad was released. I was a teenager in my penultimate year of high school and now I am nearing the end of a year of pre-retirement leave and about five and half weeks from officially starting my retirement. An ocean of water has passed under the bridge in my life since that time.

When, in May 1985, Brian Mannix asked us ‘where would we be in 50 years?’, we all felt almost immortal. I know that I did. Yet most of that time has already elapsed and I myself see myself increasingly confronted by my growing mortality. Only eleven years are left until that question is answered.

Brian Mannix has himself offered a tentative answer to that question in his 2018 solo release, Tomorrow:

I don’t have to do a thing tomorrow

Tomorrow might not come at all.

I suppose, as the title of their debut album 39 years ago reminded us, Life does hurt. But it is still well worth living and grasping to the last breath.

Compogate – Or Turning the Tables on Kathy Gallagher

I am rather embarrassed to admit this, but many years ago I was friends with a mad keen Collingwood supporter.  He was not typical of the rabid Collingwood supporter, mind you: he still had all his teeth, no tattoos, no criminal record, and had recently completed his law degree.

We were close enough friends that I was invited to his wedding, where we were all compelled at the reception to join him in singing ‘Good Old Collingwood Forever!’.   [It is to my lasting shame that I do know the words of that song.]

Apart from the rendition of the theme song, the reception was a pretty normal sort of wedding.  It was held in the hall next to his family’s parish church, there were the usual complement of groomsmen and bridesmaids etc, and all the right people made the sort of speeches about how great the newly weds were together.  [They divorced within a decade or so, in case you were wondering. Nor did I get invited to his second wedding as the friendship had died around the time the first marriage did.] 

And as happens at just about every wedding reception or gala dinner I have been to, the tables were numbered, although I do wonder whether or not my erstwhile friend was tempted to name them after Collingwood premiership coaches and captains.  It was not the fashion in 1991 to release doves from a basket outside the church, but it is just as well this idea did not occur to the wedding planner, as I don’t think releasing magpies from a basket would have ended well.

The news report that David Sharaz and Brittany Higgins have just officially gotten married in Queensland has got me wondering about how the wedding planning went, particularly the reception.

You see, the starter wedding of David Sharaz, current partner of Brittany Higgins, had some more bizarre features to ornament the wedding reception.  One was featuring official photos of the happy (not for long) couple holding rescue cats, rather than being surrounded by either the bridal party or close family and friends.  Another, more intriguingly given Mr Sharaz was a journalist at the Canberra Press Gallery, was that the tables at the reception were not numbered, but rather, they were named after Federal Labor Party leaders. [Although that might have had more to do with the fact that Mrs Sharaz mark 1 was a one eyed Labor tragic and staffer.]

You get the idea: the Shorten table, the Gillard table, the Rudd table, the Whitlam table etc.  I expect that the closest family and friends would have been put on either the Curtin table or the Hawke table, and that the C-listers would have been put on the Calwell or Hayden table.

I doubt very much that there would have been a Cook, Hughes, Lyons, or Latham table.

Knowing from news reports that Kathy Gallagher had been invited to this 2018 wedding, as she was regarded by Mr Sharaz as a dear friend, although she did not attend, has seriously picqued my curiosity.  Which table would she have been placed on if she had graciously RSVPed her attendance? Is she dear enough a friend to merit being on the Hawke, Curtin, Chifley or Whitlam tables?  Is she a little more than just a work friend, meriting the Keating, Gillard or Rudd tables?  Or is she just there as someone they wanted to curry favour to, and hence only getting placed on something like the Shorten table?  And what do they think of someone who gets placed on the Evatt or Calwell table?

I am not sure about the Forde table – probably where the doddering maiden aunt or embarrassingly drunken uncle gets placed in the far corner.

Which leads me to the issue which has been foremost in the minds of our Canberra Bubbleers this past year, given compensation payments and a certain defamation case – how well did Kathy Gallagher know David Sharaz, and when exactly did she find out about the allegations which were going to be raised around the alleged sexual assault of Miss Higgins at Parliament House in 2019?

This issue of foreknowledge is important to us taxpayers.  As Minister of State responsible for administering the Department of Finance, Senator Gallagher is responsible for making decisions under various Acts of Parliament, including those administering the Commonwealth’s worker’s compensation scheme (ComCare), and other related liability insurances (ComCover).  She also would be responsible for decision making on any Act of Grace payment outside of those liabilities.  

This means that she was responsible for authorising the confidential payment to Brittany Higgins in settlement of the lawsuit which she had bought aside the Commonwealth in relation to any injuries she may have incurred as a result of the incident in 2019.  She also would have been involved in the decision to settle the matter, although I suspect that under the terms of the ComCare and ComCover legislation, it would be possible to mount a vigourous defence in relation to claimed liabilities incurred where someone entered a Commonwealth premise outside of their normal working hours and in a severely intoxicated state.

As a decision maker in such matters, it would have been appropriate for her to declare any potential conflicts of interest and prior relationship with any of the parties privy to this settlement.  

However, it appears that Senator Gallagher has denied any fore knowledge of the 2019 incident before it was made public by Miss Higgins, and any imputation that her conduct in making decisions on the settlement were influenced by either personal friendship or political expediency.

Parliament House is a workplace where occupational hazards and incidents will and do occur  – and it appears that this particular incident has resulted in an exceptionally fast and generous compensation payout (it is a confidential figure so we do not know the exact amount).  However, in other cases, where there are incidents or workplace injuries which occur that do not involve high profile or well connected employees, they do not get the expeditious settlement of their workplace injury claims by ComCare or ComCover.

In this case, a settlement was reached which is both generous and expeditious.  If this is a reasonable standard, then other employees in Parliament and elsewhere deserve similar treatment?  And to what extent should the taxpayer wear the significant expense of this standard, which is in this case significantly beyond what victims of crime in similar cases can expect.

I consider that it well may be that this settlement was a reasonable outcome, and that it may have been appropriate for Senator Gallagher to make the decision herself rather than step aside for someone else to do so.  However, if she has misled the Parliament and the public about her relationship with Sharaz and her foreknowledge of the 2019 incident, then it is reminiscent of the Watergate scandal – Nixon was forced out of his job not because of the burglary committed by his henchmen, but by his involvement in covering it up.

Hence I call this current matter Compogate.

But I am dying to know answers to several current burning questions, namely: whether Senator Gallagher was invited to David Sharaz’s latest wedding, whether the tables were again named after Labor leaders, and which such-named table she was seated at?

Just Like The Road Runner: Mad Max Remains Fun And Relevant

As a child, I was fond of watching the old Warner Brothers cartoons, you know: Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, Porky Pig, Sylvester the Cat, and of course the Road Runner.

Road Runner is an amusing cartoon series, where the laws of physics, particularly those of gravity, are defied, and there are frequent explosions and high velocity crashes as the Coyote pursues the Road Runner across the desert. Apparently this did inspire the most violence amongst children of any cartoon show, although I have no source to cite for this assertion other than one of my high school teachers.

The closest thing to Road Runner in modern cinema is the Mad Max franchise. The plot of each film consists of a Road Runner-like hero (Mad Max) defying the Coyotesque villains (all of whom seem almost to be mutants in their grotesqueness) in a race across a post apocalyptic wasteland involving high speeds, ultra violence, and many crashes and explosions.

One of the improvements over Road Runner in Mad Max is that the villains have some pretty good lines – particularly the Lord Humungus (the Ayatollah of the Rock and Rolla) in Mad Max 2. Not Shakespearean by any means, but the villains are quite entertaining.

I believe that Mad Max 3 (ie Beyond Thunderdome) might have been the last film I saw at the Grand Footscray, back in August 1985. [For those who are curious, the Grand closed down as a cinema in 1987 and became a bingo hall for a few years, and has since then been disused for very many years.]

It took 30 years for Mad Max 4 (Fury Road) to come out. Sadly, Mel Gibson was gone from the role that made him a star, but I did not mind seeing Tom Hardy step into it, and for Charlize Theron as the Imperator Furiosa (although as a student of Latin, I am offended by the incorrect gender usage – she should have been the Imperatrix Furiosa).

Now, almost a decade later, we have a prequel to Mad Max 4, Furiosa, which focuses on that most interesting of the supporting characters in that film. Anya Taylor-Joy takes over the role originated by Theron a decade ago, and does a great job of it.

Commentators have been talking about the failure of Furiosa at the box office, despite all the hype leading up to it. There probably will be some arguing that having a female lead is another of those instances of Go Woke, Go Broke, and perhaps that is the case, as it appears to be in the Disneyfication of Star Wars.

But that does not really matter to me. Furiosa is a very fun film, just as the Road Runner cartoons are fun. We have everyone having fun playing the roles of monstrous and narcissistic villains, and lots of car chases and explosions. The henchmen are, as they always have been, a heady blend of pathetic and grotesque, particularly Scrotus and Rectus (I laughed out loud when they were introduced).

The scene where the warlord Dementus comes with his bikie hoarde to the Citadel and tries to persuade the denizens of this fortress to displace their ruler, Immortan Joe, has the sort of soliloquy that is reminiscent of the Lord Humungus in Mad Max 2. It is not going to get Chris Hemsworth an Oscar nomination, but I enjoyed it just as much as when I watched the earlier Mad Max films.

And having Furiosa as the main character? I did not mind it at all, particularly as she has been given more depth than what we had previously known about her, and arguably more than Mad Max himself (although character development is not really that important or necessary in Mad Max).

And she does a fantastic job of shooting people, running people over, and blowing things up, which is what Mad Max movies really are all about.

Just like the Road Runner.

The McBride Case – A Plea For Mercy

The sentencing of War Crimes whistleblower David McBride to over 5 years in prison last week was a sad day for justice in Australia.

He is, to this point in time, the only person to be imprisoned in relation to the war crimes which were allegedly committed by Australians in Afghanistan.

Six months ago, when he pleaded guilty after his main defence, that his conscience overrode his legal obligations, was rejected by the courts, I wrote about the situation in this blog:

Australia’s Own Dreyfus Affair

As I conceded then, the law has been broken and it is the place of the courts to punish the law breaker in accordance with the law.

A couple of days ago, I watched the commentary by the popular political vlogger Friendly Jordies on the sentencing on his YouTube channel:

My political beliefs are on the whole, rather different from those of Friendly Jordies, but I think we do share a sense of justice and fairness.

David McBride has been dealt with very harshly by the courts in comparison to some legitimate criminals who commit rapes and similar violent crimes. His only crime came from following his conscience to do what he believed served a higher purpose of justice.

He is now being punished for that. Given that the decision was made to persecute him under the laws of the land, and to reject the legitimacy of the defence argument he raised, this is as it should be.

However, the issue of conscience, and whether there are other, extenuating, circumstances here beyond that of a typical lawbreaker, is something which really should be examined further.

I believe, given that the bipartisan decision was made to initiate and persist with the prosecution, that it is up to the elected leadership of the nation to determine whether justice has been sufficiently served now, and whether it would be appropriate to consider pardoning David McBride and releasing him.

An example has been made which will deter others from whistle blowing on national secrets which will trouble the consciences of the secret keepers. He is no on going threat to either national security or to the community. Showing mercy and pardoning him now would be a just outcome, and make us think better of our elected officials.

Broo removed from ASX

Discovered just now when checking my Commsec account that Broo is no longer listed on the ASX.

When a company is removed from the ASX or changes its code, the result is rather Orwellian: it’s as if it has ceased to exist and never existed. Finding information about it needs to be done by other means than just your stock broking app or the ASX website.

As it turns out, an announcement last Monday was made by ASX compliance that as it has been suspended from trading for two years, it is removed from the ASX list.

The listing itself was one of the few items of value remaining as a tangible asset to Broo. This makes it coming back in some form ot other that little bit harder.

Ain’t I glad that I did not participate in the float at 20 cents per share 8 years ago.

Someone really doesn’t like our local MP Ben Carroll…

Saw the below when in Keilor Road yesterday. Obviously someone has gone to a lot of effort to express their dislike of our local state MP.

Not sure whether it’s anything particlar in relation to his ministerial duties or simply that he is a senior member of a government who ruthlessly suppressed legitimate expressions of protest during the pandemic.

In any case, we are lucky in Australia that this is about as extreme as political protest gets.

Brisbane Olympics 2032 – A Missed Opportunity?

I first visited Brisbane in July 1989, and I happened to go along to see the Britain – Australia Rugby Union Test (I think these days Rugby Union in the UK is so well developed that they have four separate teams instead of one, but I am not one to pay close attention to Rugby Union at the best of times).

The test was at Ballymore, a Rugby Union ground which was far less than a stadium at the time. I get the impression that it was two embankments bulldozed upward on either side of the pitch for the benefit of spectators rather than properly constructed pavilions or stands. Very outer suburban.

I was used to the VFL crowds of the era, but Queensland Rugby Union fans were next level (even when compared to Collingwood supporters at home). On the way into the ground, my friends and I encountered an acquaintance who already seemed quite drunk (it was 11am), and what appeared to be mostly still full beer cans were flying around the ground during the match.

Oh my! This makes the utter tossers who support Melbourne Victory in the domestic soccer competition seem well behaved in comparison! (Of course, we are all familiar with the private schoolboy saying that Rugby Union is a thug’s game played by gentlemen. And presumably watched by thugs too.)

Queensland sport, both in terms of its spectators’ behaviour and the facilities for viewing it, have improved a lot since then. I was in the Storey Bridge Hotel near the Gabba in April 2005 when there was going to be an AFL game that night, and I was told by the staff that after the recent threepeat, the Brisbane Lions were as popular on game day as the Brisbane Broncos (ie the long established Rugby League team). In August 2015 I went with a friend to see the Bulldogs-Brisbane game at the Gabba and was quite delighted by the comfort and accessibility of the relatively recently rebuilt Gabba stadium. (The Bulldogs lost a see-sawing game, but I did not mind too much, and the following year we did win the premiership, which made up for decades of disappointment.)

Ballymore too apparently is a somewhat improved stadium, although no longer as important for any form of football as it was 35 years ago.

The upcoming Brisbane Olympics in 2032 initially raised high hopes for taking sporting stadia in Queensland to a much better level. The original plan was for the Gabba to be rebuilt as a 50,000 seat stadium rather than the current 40,000 seat configuration.

The Labor government has since reviewed its plans and shelved the idea of rebuilding the Gabba. Whilst this is not as ruthless as the Andrews Labor Government in Victoria first accepting the 2026 Commonwealth Games and then cancelling it in what appears to have been a cynical exercise in pre-election pork barrelling, it is prima facie a matter of some concern. After all, the Olympics is usually the sort of event that the overseeing government goes insane about, regardless of costs.

If I were the IOC, I would right now be rather nervous about the intentions and capacity of the Queensland Government to actually host the Olympics, and start drawing up contingency plans.

But the economics of building large sporting stadia, even in large cities like Brisbane, is somewhat questionable.

Brisbane is a city of about 2.6 million people. It hosts one AFL team, and various other teams in the various inferior football codes. The AFL team, the Brisbane Lions, plays its home games at the Gabba. At best, this makes for 11 home games in a year, plus possible home finals matches. (The exception to this is when in the Covid cursed 2020 AFL season, the AFL lifeboated the entire competition to Brisbane.) There is also a cricket test sometime in the summer, as well as various international limited over matches.

Let’s compare that to Perth Stadium or Adelaide Oval. They have two AFL teams each, so in a usual year, those fine stadia will host a minimum 22 AFL games (to say nothing of the current Gather Round in South Australia), possibly more if their teams are firing up in the finals. And they are as likely to have as many cricket matches as Brisbane.

And then there is the MCG, the global cathedral of both Australian Rules Football and Cricket. Aside from the usual number of cricket matches, including the marquee Boxing Day Test, the MCG also hosts a minimum of 45 AFL matches per year, plus AFL finals, including the AFL Grand Final (ie the most highly attended domestic competition final in the world). With 9 AFL teams located in Greater Melbourne, there is considerable economy of scale to enable both the successful existence of the 100,000 seat MCG and the 57,000 seat Docklands Stadium.

Plus Taylor Swift and similar concerts. Top tier acts are going to perform at the MCG, whilst second tier will go to Docklands, and third tier acts like the sort I like seeing will perform at Melbourne Park. (Sadly, the sort of musicians I really really like, eg Suzanne Vega, are related to the Palais these days, and previously to Hamer Hall and Crown Casino.)

Ultimately, and I hate to say this (especially as I have been a loud advocate for rebuilding the Gabba much much bigger than it currently is), it makes very little economic sense to build any major sporting stadia anywhere approximating half the scale of the MCG anywhere but Melbourne, as they will not be used sufficiently enough to warrant the large expense.

For this to change, there would need to be more AFL matches held in other cities, which would necessitate more AFL teams being admitted to the competition – something I do not think is viable except in Perth or Adelaide. Alternatively, more Rugby or Association Football matches would need to be held in such stadia common used for AFL or Cricket.

And would we really want that?

All Care, No Responsibility? Bonza Airlines Crashes (Metaphorically)

Having a particular interest in the English language, I like reading books like The Story Of English and Bill Bryson’s Mother Tongue, and biographies on lexologists like Dr Samuel Johnson and the murderous lunatic (I kid you not) who helped build the original Oxford Dictionary.

One word whose obscure origins do vaguely confound me, but which does fascinate me, is the Australian English term ‘bogan’. Prior to the late 1980s, we would use words like yobbo or ocker to describe someone of somewhat uncouth or vulgar mannerisms and behaviour.

Since then however, bogan has gradually become the word we commonly use across Australia for such individuals.

It appears to have its origins in the Irish surname Bogan. I met someone with that surname about 15 years ago actually, and there is a wine (I have a bottle of it in fact) which is named The Bogan, which was gifted to me last year on retirement and which is far more expensive than what actual true bogans would drink.

There is a Bogan Court in Boronia, in the far outer eastern suburbs of Melbourne. I have never visited it, and I have only very briefly passed through Boronia itself, but I have always had a vague feeling that bogan started as a description of people from that area, permeating out in to the rest of Melbourne from there.

In the early 1990s, there was a TV show called the Comedy Company, featuring a faux school girl Kylie Mole (stage name for the comedienne Marianne Fahey) who would rant at the camera in a mock Broad Australian accent, regularly using the word ‘bogan’ to describe various of her acquaintances and frenemies.

And hence it spread out on the airwaves across Australia, displacing other more local words which had similar meanings.

Let’s look at the words I have collected from my travels and acquaintances across our nation which have meanings similar, if not identical, to ‘bogan’ and which have been largely displaced by our fond Melbourne term of endearment:

Sydney – Westie

Brisbane – Bevan

Perth – Turbo

Canberra – Booner

Hobart – Chigger or Chigwell.

I have not yet discovered what similar term might have existed in Adelaide, and that does bug me.

But this does go to show how Melbourne is culturally dominant in Australia, that our particular version of the Australian English dialect is the one that is most influential. [Editors of the Macquarie dictionary, please do take note. This is important for lasting records of our language.]

Vires Acquirit Eundo! As our Founding Fathers would have said!

Bogan is, to put it mildly, a term used to describe a lot of things that people from my side of the city might like, or that people from my home town might be.

I don’t really mind that. After all, I just fessed up on Facebook to a former colleague as to why I am so fond of Titus Andronicus (mostly because it is Shakespeare’s equivalent of a Road Runner cartoon).

The elitist armchair socialists at The Guardian recently wrote about the existence of a bogan airline. They could have been talking about Jetstar or Virgin Australia (neither of which I am particularly keen on travelling with), but they were not. It turned out they were talking about a challenger called Bonza, which was going to offer direct disounted flights to the bogan market.

Bonza is very much the sort of colloquial Australian expression which could be used by a bogan to describe something which provides one with joy, a bit like Germans use Wunderbar! and Cartman’s Ginger hordes of the night use Huzzah!

Indeed, a google search under the term ‘bogan airline’ yields Bonza Airline’s website as the top hit, greeting us with the sentence: ‘G’day, we’re Bonza, Australia’s new, and only independent, low cost airline servicing regional domestic routes.’

Routes included flights from the Sunshine Coast base (near Australia Zoo, former lair of the Crocodile Hunter) to Newcastle, Mildura, Albury and Melbourne (Avalon Airport). Having been to Newcastle, Mildura and Albury, I can assure you that these are places which bogans would greatly enjoy, although not as much as Bali.

Sadly, it appears that Bonza has just collapsed, leaving its employees and (presumably disproportionately represented) bogan passengers owed considerable money, and employees in particular extremely anxious as to whether they are going to paid in a hurry.

The collapse of Bonza does raise various questions about the morality of the conduct of its owners, who, despite the name, are not exactly bogans, nor even Australian.

Using my online subscription with The Melbourne Age as my source, I have learned that Bonza is owned by a private equity firm based in Miami, 777 Partners. At the end of 2023, two of the planes in the Bonza fleet were redirected to other airlines owned by 777 Partners. Last week, the remaining four planes were seized by AIP Capital, an investment company owned by ACAP, the parent company of 777 Partners. Those planes have been transferred to the aptly named Phoenix Aviation Capital, which is owned by ACAP. This was all apparently a surprise to the Australian based board of Bonza.

[As an aside, ‘phoenixing’ is a term often used, usually pejoratively, to describe the way bankrupt businesses can resurrect themselves under a new company structure, leaving creditors behind in the ashes of the previous company structure.]

Whilst I am not an expert in finance, nor a lawyer, I do have the normal sense of morality and decency of the ordinary person in the street. It appears to me from my above paraphrasing of the news report that the owners of Bonza have suddenly chosen to cut their losses on the business, leaving employees and customers significantly out of pocket. This does not seem at all moral or decent or ethical to me, to say the least.

But that might not be the least, even though that alone smells to high heaven to mug punters like me.

News reports in The Age on Monday have raised accusations of fraud on the part of 777 Partners. Lenders to that company have lodged a lawsuit claimed that it borrowed millions against $US 350 million of assets which either did not exist, or did not own, or which were already committed elsewhere. The lawsuit alleges that there have been fundamental breaches of agreements and double-pledging of assets backing loans to the company. Further, the relationship between 777 Partners and its parent ACAP is extremely entangled.

The people involved as the architects in this debacle are not our loveable bogans. They are sharks in suits who are feeding on our bogans. I really do hope that the courts in New York hold those people accountable, although I fear that this is not going to help the employees or passengers of Bonza in the short term.